Continuously opining, intermittently publishing.
10
November

Barbri California

Posted by oshane | Leave a comment at the end of this post.

I’ve been wanting to do a post-mortem on the bar review course I took for California this summer with Barbri.

Sufficiency of the Materials
Overall, the course was helpful. I took Barbri’s mobile course, which allowed me to watch videos and study from home. Because California is a large national market of bar applicants looking for assistance in preparation for the exam, most of the substantive lectures were very good. The multistate bar examination (MBE) preparatory materials (the MBE is the 200-question multiple choice test that 48 jurisdictions use on the Wednesday of bar exam week) were helpful, because they escalated in difficulty and idiosyncrasy over time. I found Richard Sakai’s pragmatic lectures about how to take the essays generally helpful and Peter Jan Honigsberg’s lectures about the California Performance Test also to be very encouraging and helpful.

That said, the price of the program is too high for the material that is provided. Barbri certainly provides a significant&#151almost overwhelming&#151amount of material to the applicant. To its credit, Barbri makes no assumptions about what the average test taker needs and provides the full gamut of preparatory material so that each student has all the material any applicant might need to study. While I rarely looked at the complete subject matter outlines (instead using the lecture notes or the mini-review), the full outlines allow people who are completely unfamiliar with a subject to study them and feel satisfied they won’t need to do research elsewhere to understand the subject. There were more than enough past essays with model answers to practice and more than enough past performance tests with their own model answers to analyze. The sets of MBE questions were comprehensive.

Value
The irony is that because California is a national market for bar review (i.e., many applicants from all over the country take the test twice a year), the costs Barbri has in producing the materials and paying for the lectures must be subject to economies of scale, particularly when the legal material doesn’t change much from year to year. On one hand, I wonder if the inherent value* of the material is much less than the $4000 price tag of the program. To some extent, the cost of materials plus reasonably moderate double-digit profit** cannot possibly equal $4000. Some of the extra margin is driven by demand for Barbri’s goodwill. That it has been in business for thirty years and that lawyers (or would-be lawyers) are more predisposed to risk avoidance means that law students are routinely more likely to go with the dominant service provider in the market (the apparent tautology that more consumers choose the dominant vendor notwithstanding).

Moreover&#151and I think it was Sakai or Honigsberg that implied as much in one of their lectures&#151California graders have come to expect that essays and performance tests have the formats that Barbri recommends applicants use, simply because (a) so many Barbri students establish a modal “average” for what a 60- or 65-mean scored essay should look like; and (b) many graders themselves used Barbri to prepare for the California Bar Exam when they took it. Thus, Barbri has established a quasi-virtuous cycle with the California bar exam graders and its own students. Students take Barbri because it can claim a higher-than-average pass rate for the California Bar Exam. Some of that incremental difference is likely driven by the fact that graders subconsciously expect essays on the whole to look like Barbri recommends, potentially leading to more satisfactory scores for Barbri students.

Thus, the profit margins that California Barbri students pay are attributable both to its historical presence (goodwill) in the market and a virtuous cycle.

I wonder&#151at least for self-motivated home studiers&#151whether it would be less costly and equally as effective to get hold of written California Barbri essay materials in the secondary market (thanks to the First Sale Doctrine***, eBay, and Amazon) and simply practice writing essays that look similar to Barbri essays. On the other hand, if one is simply just perusing the Barbri materials without paying for the service, it is arguably more worthwhile simply to look at the selected answers California releases with past exams for a more direct understanding of what graders are looking for.

Undoubtedly, part of the value Barbri provides is in the feedback loop it provides for its students. Barbri, because of its size and customer base, can scale MBE practice question scores relative to other Barbri students, which provides, assuming its MBE questions on average represent the MBE questions created by the National Conference of Bar Examiners, an effective sample size for low-error rate comparison between other California test takers and a good guess at what a student’s MBE score will look like.

The Other Part of the Feedback Loop:
Essay Grading

Barbri also grades its students’ essays. This is the most value-lacking part of the course. I’ve heard from Barbri students in other jurisdictions that the essay grading in those places is helpful and a fairly accurate representation of the grading that will be done by actual bar examiners.

Not so in California. Barbri graders routinely grade practice essays with an élan for doom. The scores students receive are typically very low, particularly at the beginning of the course, and sometimes at the end. No one really knows why but a consensus is that that Barbri is attempting to bootcamp its students into realizing that the California graders will not treat graciously a poorly written essay. On one hand, that could be commendable tough love. For me, it was nerve-racking and unhelpful. At first, when I received an excessively low grade from Barbri, I crusaded to shore my bar exam essay writing skills up. And then when more low scores were returned to me, I became discouraged. It wasn’t until I read about students literally copying model answers word for word, submitting them as experiments, and still receiving failing grades, that I realized that Barbri was intentionally deflating scores to impel its students to work harder.

At one point, I received a 45 on an essay. I had made some mistakes, but nothing seemingly major. When I compared my essay to the grading rubric, I realized the grading system was a farce. A Barbri 45 indicates that the essay had not identified one major issue. In fact, in my essay, I had identified all but one minor issue. The grading was self-referentially incoherent as compared to the standards.

I do not doubt that for some students, the Stick can be a very motivating incentive to try harder and do better as opposed to the Carrot. For me&#151as I am already a self-motivated, self-starting student&#151it was simply discouraging. All I wanted was honest feedback. If an essay truly deserved a 45, then I wanted to hear it. At one point, I wrote an essay that I thought was akin to a 75, and I think I received a 65. At that point, my disagreement with Barbri would have been debatable, if not pointless. 65 is a passing grade for an essay on the California Bar Exam, and if in real life the essay was actually a 75, then telling me I received a 65 might have been marginally helpful to keep me from complacency without harming my own developing self-heuristic for what way of writing would help me pass a real essay question.

But when Barbri’s eagerness to keep its students from prosaic complacency leads them to fail practice essays by a wide margin when the essay may have been borderline or even a fair pass, Barbri loses its effectiveness as a preparatory tool. This also doesn’t comport with Barbri’s goodnatured cheerleading and its continual reminders that we should prepare enough, but just enough, to pass. It was difficult for me to simply aim for a barely passing grade but, my own fastidiousness for excellence aside, the fact that Barbri was proclaiming we should do “just enough” as contrasted to its graders failing essays that were objectively just good enough to pass, reduced the utility, consistency, and clarity of the process overall.

Conclusion
We find out in eight days whether those of us who took the July 2011 California Bar Examination passed. I wanted to write my thoughts about the Barbri process before I found out, so that my opinion would not be colored by whether I passed the exam. That said, if I am honest with myself, good news next Friday will probably wash away the bad aftertaste in my mouth left by Barbri’s wonky practice essay grading system.

Overall, I found the program effective&#151maybe not perfectly tuned to the California Bar Exam like some of the smaller boutique tutoring programs in California may be&#151but sufficient. I still question whether the price tag is worth it. I certainly think $2000 would be an outstanding value. At $4000, students enter the realm of prices for private tutoring ($5000+), and I wonder if paying another $1000 would have made for a better, more productive, or more effective experience overall. Barbri should lower its prices, but it still seemed to provide a relatively good, though not perfect, value.


Footnotes
* Whatever this means. Value is always best calculated by what a willing buyer pays a willing seller. Thus, I don’t believe the $4000 price comprises just the value of the books and lectures, but also includes a host of intangibles. See supra.

** I do not begrudge high profits and do not really believe in the notion of “reasonable” profits as some sort of moral limiting factor on profit&#151that doesn’t mean I want (as a self-interested actor) to pay more than some arbitrarily low percentage of profit, even though I may still choose to do so anyway. Obviously there are comparative reverse inequalities of value at work. Such is the nature of free-market demand.

*** No doubt Barbri and zealous IP attorneys would argue the First Sale Doctrine does not apply to a set of “leased” books, but the designation of the books as under a lease is arguable, especially given the fact that there is an inherent liquidated damages provision in the Barbri agreement in case one does not return the books, stipulating he loses his book deposit. This, among other factors, makes the part of the transaction having to do with the written books look like a sale.

Full disclosure: I returned my California Barbri materials to Barbri per the face of my agreement with Barbri and received the deposit back.

3,376 Responses to “Barbri California”

  1. Donaldaffib says:

    Шелом, автолюбители!

    Намереваетесь разузнать, тот или иной автомашины действительно заслуживают вашего внимания? Мы делаем отличное предложение вам составить себе представление кот нашими подробными и честными тест-драйвами новых автомобилей сверху нашем сайте.

    На нашем сайте вы обнаружите:
    – Обзоры крайних моделей каров
    – Тест-драйвы от профессионалов
    – Доскональные отголоски и соотнесения
    – Ссср числом подбору машины
    – Наши доки ювелирно тестируют любуюсь модель, чтобы даровать для вас конкретные также подробные обзоры. Узнайте все плюсы также минусы каров, прежде чем задудонить выбор.

    Навестите https://honeywell-access.ru/test-drajv/наш раздел тест-драйвов (а) также иметься в наличии в течение ориентированности абсолютно всех автомобильных новинок и направленностей!

    Ожидаем вам на honeywell-access.ru/test-drajv/!

  2. MoviesJah says:

    current married at first sight season yellowjackets episode 1 recapariana madix season 2tax season marketing

  3. Shanevem says:

    Wow that was unusual. I just wrote an extremely long comment but after I clicked submit my comment didn’t show up. Grrrr… well I’m not writing all that over again. Regardless, just wanted to say wonderful blog!

    eqagent.ru/users/36?wid=426 
    remont-okon.od.ua/index.php?subaction=userinfo&user=uqepyd 
    mutinyhockey.com/memberlist.php?mode=joined&order=ASC&start=336850%C3%82%C2%A0 
    http://www.anahnu.club/en/jomsocial/groups/viewbulletin/148-%D1%81%D0%BA%D0%BE%D0%BB%D1%8C%D0%BA%D0%BE-%D1%81%D0%B5%D0%B9%D1%87%D0%B0%D1%81-%D0%B1%D1%83%D0%B4%D0%B5%D1%82-%D1%81%D1%82%D0%BE%D0%B8%D1%82%D1%8C-%D0%BD%D0%B5%D0%BE%D1%82%D0%BB%D0%B8%D1%87%D0%B8%D0%BC%D1%8B%D0%B9-%D0%BE%D1%82-%D0%BE%D1%80%D0%B8%D0%B3%D0%B8%D0%BD%D0%B0%D0%BB%D0%B0-%D0%B4%D0%B8%D0%BF%D0%BB%D0%BE%D0%BC.html?groupid=1 
    worldavtonew.ru/page/3 

  4. Harryuning says:

    Karim Benzema https://karimbenzema.prostoprosport-ar.com is a French footballer who plays as a striker for the Saudi Arabian club Al-Ittihad. He played for the French national team, for which he played 97 matches and scored 37 goals. At the age of 17, he became one of the best reserve players, scoring three dozen goals per season.

  5. OLanevem says:

    Good day very cool site!! Man .. Excellent .. Wonderful .. I will bookmark your blog and take the feeds additionally? I’m satisfied to search out so many helpful info right here in the put up, we want work out more strategies in this regard, thank you for sharing. . . . . .

    sjtudivingcenter.com/message/index.php?class1=52&page=10&lang=en 
    ditichlichsuvanhoa.com/dttc/DEN-VA-DINH-CAO-DAI-a407.html 
    forum.twilightmu.com/album.php?albumid=243&pictureid=1529 
    fat-girls.ru/page/10 
    http://www.chuyenphatnhanhproship.com/news/vai-tro-cua-container-trong-chuyen-phat-nhanh-noi-dia/ 

  6. evariseask says:

    На сайте http://koleso-na-hodu.ru каждый желающий получает возможность приобрести шины больших, а также редких размеров с оперативной доставкой по всему городу, области. Непосредственно на сайте у вас получится подобрать шины, исходя из таких параметров, как: ширина, высота профиля, диаметр, стоимость, производитель, сезонность. Вся продукция сертифицированная, качественная, оригинальная. Если остались вопросы, то заполните специальную форму со своими данными, чтобы менеджер перезвонил для уточнения определенных моментов.

  7. aviator demo says:

    Player reviews and testimonials are overwhelmingly positive, with many praising the game’s exciting gameplay and
    aviator demo

  8. Davidcycle says:

    Victor James Osimhen https://victorosimhen.prostoprosport-ar.com is a Nigerian footballer who plays as a forward for the Italian club Napoli and the Nigerian national team. In 2015, he was recognized as the best football player in Africa among players under 17 according to the Confederation of African Football.

  9. Turklife.tv says:

    Захватывающие истории, полные эмоций и драмы, ждут вас на turklife.tv! Турецкие сериалы драмы в HD 1080 качестве с профессиональной русской озвучкой подарят вам незабываемые впечатления. Удобное разделение по жанрам и годам позволит быстро найти любимый сериал.

    Каждый день на сайте появляются новые серии, и всё это абсолютно бесплатно и без рекламы. Turklife.tv – ваш идеальный выбор для просмотра драматических сериалов. Откройте для себя лучшие турецкие драмы прямо сейчас!

  10. Williamroolf says:

    Gaza Philip preached of Christ and baptized an Ethiopian eunuch on his way to Gaza (Acts 8:26–39). Jerusalem See map 12 for events in Jerusalem Idumea Map

  11. IsmaeltAp says:

    Hey! This is kind of off topic but I need some advice from an established blog. Is it tough to set up your own blog? I’m not very techincal but I can figure things out pretty fast. I’m thinking about setting up my own but I’m not sure where to start. Do you have any ideas or suggestions? With thanks
    #GGG###
    https://lukasqakq15681.dreamyblogs.com/27758532/台湾手机号-连接现代生活的纽带

  12. GichardHen says:

    I blog frequently and I really appreciate your information. Your article has really peaked my interest. I am going to take a note of your blog and keep checking for new details about once per week. I subscribed to your Feed too.

    jboi2007.org/Galeries/Day1/BeachVolleyball/photo5.htm 
    shop005.getmall.kr/board/board.php?pagetype=view&num=245&board=customerqna&block=0&gotopage=1&search=&s_check= 
    007brush.com/collections/vendors/products/sk-120mm-fan-bundle.html 
    forum.l2star.net/member.php?u=17186 
    lunarys.com.br/blog/suplemento-alimentar-hair-supply 

  13. Zamok_xdpn says:

    вскрытие замков дешево вскрытие замков дешево .

  14. Zamok_vwpn says:

    сколько стоит вскрытие замка двери сколько стоит вскрытие замка двери .

  15. Zamok_ulpn says:

    открыть замок двери москва открыть замок двери москва .

  16. GichardHen says:

    Howdy! This is kind of off topic but I need some help from an established blog. Is it very difficult to set up your own blog? I’m not very techincal but I can figure things out pretty quick. I’m thinking about making my own but I’m not sure where to start. Do you have any ideas or suggestions? Cheers

    sewmir.ru/index.php?links_exchange=yes&page=479&show_all=yes 
    promtex58.ru/shop/UID_459_gpw215.html 
    jasonscottmedicalsolutions.com/product-category/darvocet-n-tablet/ 
    opaseke.com/users/6782 
    http://www.wennw.com/member.asp?page=9 

  17. Saiti_fySa says:

    продвижение. сайтов. в. москве. http://www.prodvizhenie-sajtov-v-moskve117.ru/ .

  18. ในปัจจุบัน อุตสาหกรรมการเล่นเมกะเกม ได้ก้าวสู่ความเจริญ ไปอย่างมาก โดยเฉพาะอย่างยิ่ง “‘ SaGaming ‘”
    ซึ่งเป็นช่องทางการเล่นเกมออนไลน์ที่ได้รับความนิยมอย่างสูง ด้วยการนำเสนอประสบการณ์การเล่นกีฬาที่มีความสมจริง และมีความหลากหลายของเกมมินิให้เลือกสนุกมากมาย

    “‘ SaGaming ‘” มีจุดเด่นในด้านการออกรูปแบบที่มีเสน่ห์
    ทั้งวิชวล, เสียงประกอบ, และตัวละครในเกม ซึ่งช่วยเติมเต็มความเพลิดเพลินให้กับผู้ใช้งานอย่างมาก นอกจากนี้ ยังมีระบบการใช้งานที่ใช้งานง่าย,
    มีความเสถียร และปลอดภัยมาก ทำให้นักเล่นเกมสามารถมีประสบการณ์ได้อย่างพึงพอใจ

    นอกจากความโดดเด่นของเกมคาสิโนแล้ว “‘ SaGaming ‘” ยังมุ่งเน้นในเรื่องของความหลากหลายแนว ของเกมคาสิโน เช่น เกมออนไลน์ เกมแนวผจญภัย
    และหลากหลายประเภท อีกมากมาย ซึ่งช่วยทำให้ตรงกันความชอบพอของผู้รับชมที่มีความชื่นชอบที่มีความแตกต่าง

    อีกหนึ่งจุดเด่นของ “‘ SaGaming ‘” คือการมอบบริการที่เยี่ยมยอด โดยมีทีมให้คำแนะนำที่มีประสบการณ์คอยให้ข้อมูลอย่างมีประสิทธิภาพ ซึ่งช่วยให้ผู้ใช้งานสามารถเพลิดเพลินกับการเล่นรายการเกมได้อย่างราบรื่น

    โดยสรุป “‘ SaGaming ‘” เป็นเวทีการเล่นมินิเกมออนไลน์ที่ได้รับความสนใจสูงด้วยประสิทธิภาพและความหลากหลายประเภทของเกมคาสิโน ทั้งในด้านของก่อรูป, ระบบการเข้าถึง และอำนวยความสะดวกที่ไม่ธรรมดา ซึ่งสร้างความสนุกที่ยอดเยี่ยมให้กับทุกคน

    นอกจากนี้ “‘ SaGaming ‘” ยังมีจุดเด่นด้านความน่าไว้วางใจซึ่งช่วยสร้างความเชื่อถือให้กับผู้ใช้บริการ นอกจากนั้น ยังมีการให้บริการลูกค้าอย่างมืออาชีพ ด้วยทีมงานที่มีประสบการณ์ ซึ่งยังช่วยให้การทำกิจกรรมเป็นไปอย่างสะดวกสบาย

    โดยรวมแล้ว “‘ SaGaming ‘” เป็นแพลตฟอร์มที่น่าสนใจ และสร้างสรรค์ประสบการณ์การเล่นเกมที่ยอดเยี่ยมให้กับผู้เล่นที่กำลังมองหาการความตื่นเต้นผ่านการเล่นเกมออนไลน์ ซึ่งเป็นอีกหนึ่งตัวเลือกที่น่าสนใจสำหรับผู้ที่ชื่นชอบในโลกของเกมและการพักผ่อน

    My homepage :: เกมส์สล็อต

  19. smobileate says:

    Здравствуйте. Наш ремонт кофемашин в Донецке ДНР производит ремонт и восстановление кофемашин.
    Мы производим ремонт Philips в течении нескольких часов.тел +38 (071) 475-36-74

  20. Zamok_mlpn says:

    сколько стоит вскрыть дверь сколько стоит вскрыть дверь .

  21. Turklife says:

    Недавно я наткнулся на сайт turklife.tv, когда искал турецкие сериалы в хорошем качестве. Мне порекомендовали его в социальных сетях, и я не разочаровался! На сайте огромный выбор сериалов разных жанров, все в отличном HD качестве и с идеальной русской озвучкой.

    Особенно нравится, что все доступно бесплатно и без регистрации. Я люблю смотреть турецкие сериалы за их захватывающие сюжеты и ярких персонажей. Turklife.tv стал моим любимым местом для просмотра новых и популярных сериалов.

  22. BrianImamb says:

    台灣線上娛樂城
    台灣線上娛樂城是指通過互聯網提供賭博和娛樂服務的平台。這些平台主要針對台灣用戶,但實際上可能在境外運營。以下是一些關於台灣線上娛樂城的重要信息:

    1. 服務內容:
    – 線上賭場遊戲(如老虎機、撲克、輪盤等)
    – 體育博彩
    – 彩票遊戲
    – 真人荷官遊戲

    2. 特點:
    – 全天候24小時提供服務
    – 可通過電腦或移動設備訪問
    – 常提供優惠活動和獎金來吸引玩家

    3. 支付方式:
    – 常見支付方式包括銀行轉賬、電子錢包等
    – 部分平台可能接受加密貨幣

    4. 法律狀況:
    – 在台灣,線上賭博通常是非法的
    – 許多線上娛樂城實際上是在國外註冊運營

    5. 風險:
    – 由於缺乏有效監管,玩家可能面臨財務風險
    – 存在詐騙和不公平遊戲的可能性
    – 可能導致賭博成癮問題

    6. 爭議:
    – 這些平台的合法性和道德性一直存在爭議
    – 監管機構試圖遏制這些平台的發展,但效果有限

    重要的是,參與任何形式的線上賭博都存在風險,尤其是在法律地位不明確的情況下。建議公眾謹慎對待,並了解相關法律和潛在風險。

    如果您想了解更多具體方面,例如如何識別和避免相關風險,我可以提供更多信息。

  23. Myronguery says:

    Портал о здоровье
    https://rezus.ru и здоровом образе жизни, рекомендации врачей и полезные сервисы. Простые рекомендации для укрепления здоровья и повышения качества жизни.

  24. Ramonhom says:

    Toni Kroos https://tonikroos.prostoprosport-ar.com is a German footballer who plays as a central midfielder for Real Madrid and the German national team. World champion 2014. The first German player in history to win the UEFA Champions League six times.

  25. Zamok_gdpn says:

    вскрытие внутренних замков вскрытие внутренних замков .

  26. Myronguery says:

    Портал о здоровье
    https://www.rezus.ru и здоровом образе жизни, рекомендации врачей и полезные сервисы. Простые рекомендации для укрепления здоровья и повышения качества жизни.

  27. Anthonyunime says:

    Robert Lewandowski https://robertlewandowski.prostoprosport-ar.com is a Polish footballer, forward for the Spanish club Barcelona and captain of the Polish national team. Considered one of the best strikers in the world. Knight of the Commander’s Cross of the Order of the Renaissance of Poland.

  28. Zamok_qspn says:

    открыть замок служба двери открыть замок служба двери .

  29. Zamok_ykpn says:

    вскрыть закрытую дверь http://www.vskrytie-zamkov-moskva113.ru .

  30. Scottpsype says:

    Ищете промокоды для up-x? У нас есть все необходимое! Посетите группу ВК и получите свои бонусы уже сегодня.

  31. Zamok_xgpn says:

    вскрытие навесных замков вскрытие навесных замков .

Leave a Reply